Commons:Deletion requests/File:Taoyuan Metro logo seal only.svg
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
This image is believed to be non-free or possibly non-free in its home country, Taiwan, as required by Commons:Licensing. From Taoyuan Metro:
| “ | All contents published on the Taoyuan Metro official website other than the items not being the subject of copyright which was regulated by Copyright Act (e.g.: law and order. Please see Article 9 of Copyright Act for reference.), including but not limited to, text report, photograph, image, illustration, audio, video, file, website arrangement and webpage design, were protected from Copyright Act of the Republic of China and international copyright laws. For those contents of this website which were protected by Copyright Act, they shall not be used before consent or authorization of the copyright owner except for the condition of reasonable use. | ” |
Szqecs (talk) 14:56, 10 November 2018 (UTC)
- This image is applicable for PD-text, PD-ROC-exempt. Please be noted all similar files shall be deleted (i.e.Category:Logos_of_rail_transport_companies_of_Taiwan) under the argument as this is causing ambiguous situation. --@assanges (talk | cont | uploads)
- This image is applicable for PD-text, PD-ROC-exempt. PD-text applies only to text, which this is not. None of the conditions of PD-ROC-exempt applies. Please be noted all similar files shall be deleted (i.e.Category:Logos_of_rail_transport_companies_of_Taiwan). Taipei Metro allows its works to be used freely, not other rail operators in Taiwan. So yes, unless proven to be free, they should be deleted too. Szqecs (talk) 17:02, 10 November 2018 (UTC)
- Note that PD-text is applicable for images consists only of simple geometric shapes or text, now I do have doubts about insisting on deletion. --@assanges (talk | cont | uploads) 16:06, 12 November 2018 (UTC)
- I think you are referring to {{PD-textlogo}}. Whether a logo consisting of geometric shapes is "simple" depends on whether it meets the threshold of [Commons:Threshold of originality originality], which depends on the country. In Taiwan, this threshold is low. Works with "minimal creativity" are eligible for copyright protection. Szqecs (talk) 06:08, 14 November 2018 (UTC)
- Note that PD-text is applicable for images consists only of simple geometric shapes or text, now I do have doubts about insisting on deletion. --@assanges (talk | cont | uploads) 16:06, 12 November 2018 (UTC)
- This image is applicable for PD-text, PD-ROC-exempt. PD-text applies only to text, which this is not. None of the conditions of PD-ROC-exempt applies. Please be noted all similar files shall be deleted (i.e.Category:Logos_of_rail_transport_companies_of_Taiwan). Taipei Metro allows its works to be used freely, not other rail operators in Taiwan. So yes, unless proven to be free, they should be deleted too. Szqecs (talk) 17:02, 10 November 2018 (UTC)