Viewing filter 458: Feedback: Extremely short post

Filter parameters

Filter ID:	458
Description: (publicly viewable)
Filter hits:	46,898 hits
Conditions: (documentation)	!("autoconfirmed" in user_groups) & (new_size > 0 & new_size < 10) !("autoconfirmed" in user_groups) & (new_size > 0 & new_size < 10)
Notes:	Prevents all-caps comments in AFTv5. Disabling. Why is it necessary to disallow shouting? It may be impolite but it's not all in bad faith. Plus there's the potential for FPs such as all-caps abbreviations. - KoH Reenable with disallow off. - KoH Enabled this filter with only an auto-flag action, to test that feature on production. All this does is indicate to editors that there could be an issue with this post, as is often the case with people who type their entire comments in all-caps. - Fabrice Florin Changed the setting of this feedback filter to be included in the 'Feedback' filter group, which was recently implemented by Werdna (Andrew Garrett) to separate edit filter actions from feedback filter actions,so that feedback filters don't impact condition limits for edit filters. - Fabrice Florin - May 17, 2012 Dropped the action check, as the group setting makes it unnecessary. -Rsterbin Dropped the warning filter, which is not appropriate for feedback filters (until Werdna revises the tool). Only kept auto-flag for now, because it is unfair to reject someone's post just because they are shouting. Auto-flag should suffice to warn editors of possible abuse. -- Fabrice Florin, June 6, 2012. Disabling - too many false positives. Oliver Keyes, July 21, 2012 New filter. Moved from filter 460. -Sole Soul Hit the >5% of actions by itself, and all edits were garbage or vandalism. -- Oliver Keyes (WMF) Upped to 10 chars to try and reduce the number of hits. Short-term, experimental fix :). -- Oliver Keyes (WMF) The above action quickly disabled the filter. After my call with Oliver, I realized that upping the number of chars would INCREASE the number of hits even more, so I am now lowering the number of chars down to 3, to see if that solves the issue. Short-term, experimental fix :). -- Fabrice Florin (WMF) Re-enabling this filter, now that we have deployed a fix to prevent from being disabled after only a few posts. Hopefully it will work better now. I am setting it up for posts that are shorter than 5 characters, as initially intended by Sole Soul. Fingers crossed. -- Fabrice Florin This filter was automatically disabled with a setting of 5 characters or less, so I am lowering that threshold to disallow posts that have 4 characters or less, to see if it works. -- Fabrice This filter was automatically disabled with a setting of 4 characters or less, so I am lowering that threshold to disallow posts that have 3 characters or less, to see if it works. -- Fabrice This filter was automatically disabled with a setting of 3 characters or less, so I am lowering that threshold to disallow posts that have 2 characters or less, to see if it works. -- Fabrice Florin To enable filtering for very short posts of 10 characters or less, we have now made a change to the Abuse filter extension to increase the threshold that disables filters if they exceed 5% of total actions, raising it to 10% (but only for filters that are in the feedback group, leaving other filters untouched). To test that this change is working as intended, I will start by disallowing posts with 10 characters or less. If that works and the filter is not disabled, then it means that our change did the job. If the filter is disabled at 10 characters, then I will go down to 9 characters or less, then 8 characters or less, until we reach a stable state. Fingers crossed .... -- Fabrice Florin Oct. 26, 2012 This filter was automatically disabled at 10 characters over the weekend, even though we increased the limit to 10% of feedback actions ('matching more than 10.00% of actions'), so I am trying it out again with 9 characters -- Fabrice Florin - Oct. 29, 2012 Auto-disabled at 9 characters as well, testing 8. -mlitn Auto-disabled a couple hours later at 8 characters, so I am trying it out again with 7 characters -- Fabrice Florin - Oct. 29, 2012 Auto-disabled at 7 characters as well, testing 6. -mlitn Auto-disabled at 6 characters as well, testing 5. -- Fabrice Florin - Nov. 13, 2012 Auto-disabled at 5 characters as well, testing 4. -- Fabrice Florin - Nov. 19, 2012 Re-enabling now that threshold has been upped for feedback group. --mlitn - Feb. 12, 2013 Size 0 (no feedback at all) is valid --mlitn - May 14, 2013 Deleting, AFTv5 removed from WMF wikis --Legoktm 03/03/13
Flags:	Warning: This filter was automatically flagged as harmful. No actions were automatically disabled, but please check whether the high rate of matches is expected. If so, you can ignore this warning. Hide details of this filter from public view Enable this filter I understand that details of this filter will be hidden from users who cannot see [https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Extension:AbuseFilter/Rules_format#Protected_variables protected variables] Mark as deleted
Filter last modified:	20:21, 3 March 2014 by Legoktm (talk \| contribs)
History:	View this filter's history
Tools:	Export this filter to another wiki {"data":{"rules":"!(\"autoconfirmed\" in user_groups) \u0026\r\n(new_size \u003E 0 \u0026 new_size \u003C 10)","name":"Feedback: Extremely short post","comments":"Prevents all-caps comments in AFTv5.\r\n\r\nDisabling. Why is it necessary to disallow shouting? It may be impolite but it's not all in bad faith. Plus there's the potential for FPs such as all-caps abbreviations. - KoH\r\n \r\nReenable with disallow off. - KoH\r\n\r\nEnabled this filter with only an auto-flag action, to test that feature on production. All this does is indicate to editors that there could be an issue with this post, as is often the case with people who type their entire comments in all-caps. - Fabrice Florin\r\n\r\nChanged the setting of this feedback filter to be included in the 'Feedback' filter group, which was recently implemented by Werdna (Andrew Garrett) to separate edit filter actions from feedback filter actions,so that feedback filters don't impact condition limits for edit filters. - Fabrice Florin - May 17, 2012\r\n\r\nDropped the action check, as the group setting makes it unnecessary. -Rsterbin\r\n\r\nDropped the warning filter, which is not appropriate for feedback filters (until Werdna revises the tool). Only kept auto-flag for now, because it is unfair to reject someone's post just because they are shouting. Auto-flag should suffice to warn editors of possible abuse. -- Fabrice Florin, June 6, 2012.\r\n\r\nDisabling - too many false positives. Oliver Keyes, July 21, 2012\r\n\r\nNew filter. Moved from filter 460. -Sole Soul\r\n\r\nHit the \u003E5% of actions by itself, and all edits were garbage or vandalism. -- Oliver Keyes (WMF)\r\n\r\nUpped to 10 chars to try and reduce the number of hits. Short-term, experimental fix :). -- Oliver Keyes (WMF)\r\n\r\nThe above action quickly disabled the filter. After my call with Oliver, I realized that upping the number of chars would INCREASE the number of hits even more, so I am now lowering the number of chars down to 3, to see if that solves the issue. Short-term, experimental fix :). -- Fabrice Florin (WMF)\r\n\r\nRe-enabling this filter, now that we have deployed a fix to prevent from being disabled after only a few posts. Hopefully it will work better now. I am setting it up for posts that are shorter than 5 characters, as initially intended by Sole Soul. Fingers crossed. -- Fabrice Florin\r\n\r\nThis filter was automatically disabled with a setting of 5 characters or less, so I am lowering that threshold to disallow posts that have 4 characters or less, to see if it works. -- Fabrice\r\n\r\nThis filter was automatically disabled with a setting of 4 characters or less, so I am lowering that threshold to disallow posts that have 3 characters or less, to see if it works. -- Fabrice\r\n\r\nThis filter was automatically disabled with a setting of 3 characters or less, so I am lowering that threshold to disallow posts that have 2 characters or less, to see if it works. -- Fabrice Florin\r\n\r\nTo enable filtering for very short posts of 10 characters or less, we have now made a change to the Abuse filter extension to increase the threshold that disables filters if they exceed 5% of total actions, raising it to 10% (but only for filters that are in the feedback group, leaving other filters untouched). To test that this change is working as intended, I will start by disallowing posts with 10 characters or less. If that works and the filter is not disabled, then it means that our change did the job. If the filter is disabled at 10 characters, then I will go down to 9 characters or less, then 8 characters or less, until we reach a stable state. Fingers crossed .... -- Fabrice Florin Oct. 26, 2012\r\n\r\nThis filter was automatically disabled at 10 characters over the weekend, even though we increased the limit to 10% of feedback actions ('matching more than 10.00% of actions'), so I am trying it out again with 9 characters -- Fabrice Florin - Oct. 29, 2012\r\n\r\nAuto-disabled at 9 characters as well, testing 8. -mlitn\r\n\r\nAuto-disabled a couple hours later at 8 characters, so I am trying it out again with 7 characters -- Fabrice Florin - Oct. 29, 2012\r\n\r\nAuto-disabled at 7 characters as well, testing 6. -mlitn\r\n\r\nAuto-disabled at 6 characters as well, testing 5. -- Fabrice Florin - Nov. 13, 2012\r\n\r\nAuto-disabled at 5 characters as well, testing 4. -- Fabrice Florin - Nov. 19, 2012\r\n\r\nRe-enabling now that threshold has been upped for feedback group. --mlitn - Feb. 12, 2013\r\n\r\nSize 0 (no feedback at all) is valid --mlitn - May 14, 2013\r\n\r\nDeleting, AFTv5 removed from WMF wikis --Legoktm 03/03/13","group":"default","actions":{"disallow":[]},"enabled":false,"deleted":true,"privacylevel":0,"global":false},"actions":{"disallow":[]}}

Actions to take when matched

Trigger actions only if the user trips a rate limit

Number of actions to allow:

Period of time (in seconds):

Group throttle by:

user

See the documentation on mediawiki.org.

Trigger these actions after giving the user a warning

System message to use for warning:

Page name of other message:

(without "MediaWiki:" prefix)

Prevent the user from performing the action in question

System message to use for disallowing:

Page name of other message:

(without "MediaWiki:" prefix)

Revoke the user's autoconfirmed status

Tag the edit in contributions lists and page histories

Tags to apply:

(see Wikipedia:Tags for use and formatting)

(please don't rename a tag here, see link above)

(one per line, no commas, publicly visible)