Does this work for you now?

In T362269#9714170, @Paladox wrote:

Does this work for you now?

@Paladox: Has something related changed server-side in the meantime?

In T362269#9873138, @Aklapper wrote:

In T362269#9714170, @Paladox wrote:

Does this work for you now?

@Paladox: Has something related changed server-side in the meantime?

There was a gerrit update I think shortly after this task was filed.

looking at https://gerrit.wikimedia.org/r/c/mediawiki/extensions/CommunityConfiguration/+/1017814/4 I see the comment in ValidationHooks but it's resolved now so I'm not entirely sure if the problem is fixed.

Possibly related - I was complaining yesterday about Gerrit not showing me unresolved comments on a previous version of a file. So I tested a couple of things on /test/gerrit-ping, as suggested by @hashar.

While not directly what's reported (because it happens on a file modified in this review), see also this:

Note the discrepancy between the number of unresolved comments and the number of unresolved comments in the files: two of them on test-comments are not displayed there. This happens to previous comments new comments are added to the review, when new comments are moved from draft to real comments ("reply"). A reload of the page seems to solve the issue.

To reproduce on https://gerrit.wikimedia.org/r/c/test/gerrit-ping/+/1057052:

• add a comment somewhere
• click Reply and validate
• it looks like, specifically and regardless of where you put the comments, the comments on test-comments are not visible until the page gets reloaded.

I could see what is reported in this issue being a specific case of a larger issue of "sometimes comments are not shown".

Note: I observe that behaviour both on Firefox and Chrome.