Vietnamese Cambodians: Difference between revisions

Content deleted Content added
add {{verify spelling}} for "incidences"
m Added links - Genocide, Hun Sen, Longvek, Prey Nokor, Michael Vickery
(31 intermediate revisions by 14 users not shown)
Line 1:
{{Short description|Ethnic Vietnamese people in Cambodia}}{{good article}}
{{For|ethnic Cambodians in Vietnam|Khmer Krom}}
{{good article}}
{{Infobox ethnic group
| group = Vietnamese Cambodians <br><small>ជនជាតិខ្មែរវៀតណាម<br>Người Campuchia gốc Việt</small>
|group=Vietnamese Cambodians
| image = Vietnamese-floating-village-siem reap floating village1.jpg
|image=[[Image:FlotinSiemReap.jpg|250px]]
| caption = A Vietnamese boatfloating dwellersvillage in [[Siem Reap]]
| pop = '''180,000–1,000,000''' (est.)<br/>1% - 6.25% of the Cambodian population<ref>{{Cite news|date=2 July 2021|title='Please show mercy': Evicted by Cambodia, ethnic Vietnamese stuck at watery border|work=[[Reuters]]|url=https://www.reuters.com/article/us-cambodia-vietnam-evictions-idUSKCN2E75RA}}</ref>
| regions = [[Siem Reap]], [[Phnom Penh]], South-East Cambodia
| rels = [[Vietnamese folk religion]], [[Mahayana|Mahayana Buddhism]], [[Theravada|Theravada Buddhism]], [[Caodaism|Cao Dai]], [[Catholic Church|Roman Catholicism]]
| langs = [[Vietnamese language|Vietnamese]], [[Khmer language|Khmer]]
| related = [[Overseas Vietnamese]], [[Austroasiatic languages|Austroasiatic peoples]]
}}
 
'''Vietnamese Cambodians''' referrefers to ethnic group of [[Vietnamese people|Vietnamese]] livingwho live in [[Cambodia]] or it refers to Vietnamese who are of full or partial [[Khmer people|Khmer]] descent. According to Cambodian sources, in 2013 there are, about 15,000 Vietnamese people livinglive in Cambodia. A Vietnamese source saidstated there arethat 156,000 people livinglive in Cambodia,<ref>{{Cite news|date=23 September 2016|title=VN phối hợp với Campuchia đảm bảo cuộc sống người Việt|work=Ngày Nay|url=https://ngaynay.vn/vn-phoi-hop-voi-campuchia-dam-bao-cuoc-song-nguoi-viet-post25879.html}}</ref> while the actual number could be somewhere between 400,000 and one million people, according to independent scholars.<ref name="cambodia">{{cite web|url=https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2018/03/28/magazine/cambodia-persecuted-minority-water-refuge.html|title=A People in Limbo, Many Living Entirely on the Water|work=[[The New York Times]]|date=2018-03-28}}</ref> They mostly reside in southeastern parts of Cambodia bordering Vietnam or on [[boathousehouseboat]]s in the [[Tonlé Sap]] lake and [[Mekong]] rivers. The first Vietnamese came to settle modern-day Cambodia from the early 19th century during the era of the [[Nguyễn lords]] and most of the Vietnamese came to Cambodia during the periods of [[French protectorate of Cambodia|French colonial administration]] and the [[People's Republic of Kampuchea]] administration. During the [[Khmer Republic]] and [[Khmer Rouge]] governments in the 1970s under the [[Pol Pot regime]], the Vietnamese amongst others were targets of mass [[Genocide|genocides]]; thousands of Vietnamese were killed and many more sought refuge in Vietnam. Ethnic relations between the [[Cambodians]] and Vietnamese are poor and the Vietnamese have been the main target of [[Xenophobia|xenophobic]] attacks by political parties since the 1990s. Most of the Vietnamese are stateless residents of Cambodia and as a result they face difficulties in getting access to education, employment, and housing.
 
Ethnic relations between the [[Cambodians]] and Vietnamese are complex, where despite engagement and collaboration between the two countries of [[Cambodia]] and [[Vietnam]], Vietnamese have been the target of [[Xenophobia|xenophobic]] attacks by opposition political parties against [[Hun Sen]]'s policies since the 1990s.<ref>{{Cite journal |last=Heng |first=Kimkong |date=2022-04-12 |title=2022/36 “Cambodia-Vietnam Relations: Key Issues and the Way Forward” by Kimkong Heng |url=https://www.iseas.edu.sg/articles-commentaries/iseas-perspective/2022-36-cambodia-vietnam-relations-key-issues-and-the-way-forward-by-kimkong-heng/ |language=en-US |volume=2022 |issue=36}}</ref> Many of the stateless Vietnamese residents face difficulties in getting access to education, employment, and housing.<ref>https://asiafoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Cambodia-StatofConflictandViolence.pdf</ref><ref>{{Cite web |last=Christ |first=Kiernan |date=2022-06-14 |title=The Perpetual Foreigner: Statelessness among the Vietnamese Minority in Cambodia |url=https://gjia.georgetown.edu/2022/06/14/the-perpetual-foreigner-statelessness-among-the-vietnamese-minority-in-cambodia/ |access-date=2023-07-30 |website=Georgetown Journal of International Affairs |language=en-US}}</ref> Although xenophobic sentiments have been a continuing source of concern, they have not been a barrier towards neighbourly ties within the context of [[Southeast Asia]] and other international affairs.<ref>{{Cite web |last=VnExpress |title=Vietnam, Cambodia to further strengthen multifaceted relations - VnExpress International |url=https://e.vnexpress.net/news/news/vietnam-cambodia-agree-to-bolster-relations-4533645.html |access-date=2023-07-30 |website=VnExpress International – Latest news, business, travel and analysis from Vietnam |language=en}}</ref><ref>{{Cite web |date=2022-11-13 |title=Cambodia-Vietnam, a true friendship in ASEAN context - Khmer Times |url=https://www.khmertimeskh.com/501183775/cambodia-vietnam-a-true-friendship-in-asean-context/ |access-date=2023-07-30 |language=en-US}}</ref><ref>{{Cite journal |last=Heng |first=Kimkong |date=2022-04-12 |title=2022/36 “Cambodia-Vietnam Relations: Key Issues and the Way Forward” by Kimkong Heng |url=https://www.iseas.edu.sg/articles-commentaries/iseas-perspective/2022-36-cambodia-vietnam-relations-key-issues-and-the-way-forward-by-kimkong-heng/ |language=en-US |volume=2022 |issue=36}}</ref><ref>{{Cite web |title=Dialogue on War Legacies and Peace in Vietnam, Laos and Cambodia |url=https://www.usip.org/events/dialogue-war-legacies-and-peace-vietnam-laos-and-cambodia |access-date=2023-07-30 |website=United States Institute of Peace |language=en}}</ref>
 
==History==
Relations between Cambodia and Vietnam date back to when [[Chey Chettha II]], in order to balance the influence of the Siamese forces, which had devastated the previous capital at [[Longvek]] during the reign of his father, had struck an alliance with Vietnam and married Princess [[Nguyễn Phúc Ngọc Vạn]], a daughter of Lord [[Nguyễn Phúc Nguyên]], in 1618.<ref>Mai Thục, ''Vương miện lưu đày: truyện lịch sử,'' Nhà xuất bản Văn hóa - thông tin, 2004, p.580; Giáo sư Hoàng Xuân Việt, Nguyễn Minh Tiến hiệu đính, ''Tìm hiểu lịch sử chữ quốc ngữ,'' Ho Chi Minh City, Công ty Văn hóa Hương Trang, pp.31-33; Helen Jarvis, ''Cambodia,'' Clio Press, 1997, p.xxiii.</ref><ref name="nghiamvo-1623">{{cite book |author1=Nghia M. Vo |url=http://www.sacei07.org/women10.jsp |title=The Women of Vietnam |author2=Chat V. Dang |author3=Hien V. Ho |date=2008-08-29 |publisher=Outskirts Press |isbn=978-1-4327-2208-1 |series=Saigon Arts, Culture & Education Institute Forum |access-date=2010-06-17 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20160303200648/http://www.sacei07.org/women10.jsp |archive-date=2016-03-03 |url-status=dead}}</ref> In return, the king had granted the Vietnamese the right to establish settlements in Mô Xoài (now [[Bà Rịa]]), in the region of [[Prey Nokor]]—which they colloquially [[Names of Ho Chi Minh City|referred to]] as ''Sài Gòn'', and which later became [[Ho Chi Minh City]].<ref name="kamm">{{cite book |author=Henry Kamm |url=https://archive.org/details/cambodiareportfr00kamm |title=Cambodia: report from a stricken land |publisher=Arcade Publishing |year=1998 |isbn=1-55970-433-0 |page=[https://archive.org/details/cambodiareportfr00kamm/page/23 23] |quote=chey chettha II. |url-access=registration}}</ref><ref name="ngbac">{{cite web |title=Nguyễn Bặc and the Nguyễn |url=http://nguyenphuoctoc.net/doc/nguyen_bac_english.html |url-status=dead |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20090413074249/http://nguyenphuoctoc.net/doc/nguyen_bac_english.html |archive-date=2009-04-13 |access-date=2010-06-16}}</ref> Vietnamese settlers first entered the Mekong and the Prey Nokor area (later Saigon) from the 1620s onwards. The region then as now is known to the Cambodians as [[Kampuchea Krom]] but by cession and conquest (Vietnamese expansion to the South, dubbed [[Nam Tiến]]), the area came under Vietnamese control. Under the reign of [[Chey Chettha II]], Cambodia formally ceded the eastern portion to the [[Nguyễn lords]].<ref>Corfield (2009), p. 3</ref>
 
With the unification Vietnam under Emperor [[Gia Long]], the Court of Huế asserted its hegemony in 1813 and sent 10,000 troops to Phnom Penh. The Cambodian court was split into rival factions vying for power and some members of the Cambodian royal sought the support of the Vietnamese, thus implanting Vietnamese power within the kingdom.<ref>Schliesinger (2015), p. 258</ref> Favors were granted to allow more Vietnamese settlers and by the reign of Emperor [[Minh Mạng]], Vietnam chose to impose its rule directly, relegating the Cambodian court to a minor role. Administrative renaming of town and provinces was carried out while Vietnamese customs were forced upon the Cambodian populace.<ref>Kuhnt-Saptodewo (1997), p. 154</ref> The heavy-handed policies stirred resentment among the Cambodian populace, provoking protracted insurgency and unrest.<ref>Corfield (2009), pp. 17–18</ref> Vietnam was forced to withdraw, accepting the restoration of the royal candidate Ang Duong as the Cambodian king. Vietnam nonetheless joined Siam to hold Cambodia in joint vassalage.
 
In 1880 with the establishment of the [[French Protectorate of Cambodia|French colonial administration]], Cambodia joined Vietnam as part of [[French Indochina]], the status to Vietnamese residents in Cambodia was formally legalized. Over the next fifty years, large numbers of Vietnamese migrated to Cambodia.<ref>Corfield (2009), p. 28</ref> Population censuses conducted by the French recorded an increase in the Vietnamese population from about 4,500 in the 1860s to almost 200,000 at the end of the 1930s.<ref name="Sch259">Schliesinger (2015), p. 259</ref> When the [[Japanese invasion of French Indochina|Japanese invaded Indochina]] in 1940, Vietnamese nationalists in Cambodia launched a brief but unsuccessful attempt to attack the French colonial administrators.<ref>Corfield (2009), p. 40</ref>
Vietnamese settlers began to settle in modern-day [[Cochinchina]] and [[Ho Chi Minh City]] from the 1620s onwards. To the Cambodians, these lands were known as [[Kampuchea Krom]] and traditionally under the control of the [[Khmer Empire]]. From the era of [[Chey Chettha II]] onwards, they came under the control of the [[Nguyễn lords]].<ref>Corfield (2009), p. 3</ref> In 1813, Emperor [[Gia Long]] sent 10,000 Vietnamese troops into Phnom Penh and some members of the Cambodian royal family came under the control of the Vietnamese court.<ref>Schliesinger (2015), p. 258</ref> The Nguyen court imposed Vietnamese customs upon the Cambodian populace, and names of towns and provinces were changed to Vietnamese ones. Vietnamese settlers were encouraged to settle in Cambodia and official documents from the Vietnamese court recorded an average of 5,000 Vietnamese settlers coming into Cambodia in the 1830s.<ref>Kuhnt-Saptodewo (1997), p. 154</ref> The policies imposed by the Nguyen court stirred resentment among the Cambodian populace and provoked occasional rebellions.<ref>Corfield (2009), pp. 17–18</ref>
 
InWith 1880, the [[French Protectorate of Cambodia|French colonial administration]] to provide [[Citizenship|subject]] status to Vietnamese residentsindependence in Cambodia. Over the next fifty years1954, large numbers of Vietnamese migrated to Cambodia.<ref>Corfield (2009), p. 28</ref> Population censuses conducted by the French recorded an increase in the Vietnamese population from about 4,500 in the 1860s to almost 200,000 at the end of the 1930s.<ref name="Sch259">Schliesinger (2015), p. 259</ref> When the [[Japanese invasion of French Indochina|Japanese invaded Indochina]] in 1940, Vietnamese nationalists in Cambodia launched a brief but unsuccessful attempt to attack the French colonial administrators.<ref>Corfield (2009), p. 40</ref> In 1954,legislated a citizenship law was passedbased on the basis of knowledge in the Khmer language and national origin,; andthis effectively excluded most Vietnamese and [[Chinese Cambodian]]s.<ref>Ehrentraut (2013), p. 50</ref> At the grassrootsgrassroot level, Vietnamese also faced occasional cases of violent intimidation from the Cambodians. During a [[Sangkum]] congress in 1962, politicians debated on the issue of citizenship on Cambodia's ethnic minorities and a resolution was passed not to grant naturalization of Vietnamese residents.<ref name="Wil35">Willmott (1967), p. 35</ref>
 
When [[Lon Nol]] [[Cambodian coup of 1970|assumed power in 1970]], the [[Khmer Republic]] government launched a propaganda campaign to portray the ethnic Vietnamese as agents of the [[Vietcong]]. About 30,000 Vietnamese were arrested and killed in prison, while an additional tens of thousands fled to Vietnam. Five years later in 1975 when the Khmer republic met its demise at the hands of the [[Khmer Rouge]], lessfewer than 80,000 Vietnamese remained in Cambodia. whenThe the [[Khmer Rouge]] seizedproceeded power.to expel Closeclose to three quarters of them were expelledback to Vietnam, and; the remaining 20,000 whowere remainedclassified areas thosemixed who are of mixed-Vietnamese and Khmer descent. Those who remainedand were killed by the regime.<ref name="Sch260">Schliesinger (2015), p. 260</ref> By the time [[Cambodian–Vietnamese War|Vietnamese troops entered Cambodia]] in 1979, virtually all of Cambodia's Vietnamese population were either displaced or killed.<ref name="Tabeau48">Tabeau (2009), p. 48</ref> Vietnam established a new regime known as the [[People's Republic of Kampuchea]] (PRK), and Vietnamese advisers were appointed in the new government administration. In 1983, the PRK government formulated an official policy to encourage former Vietnamese residents of Cambodia to return and settle downin Cambodia. Even Vietnamese immigrants who had no family ties to Cambodia also came to settle in the country, as there was little border control to limit Vietnamese migrants from entering the country.<ref name="Eh56">Ehrentraut (2013), p. 56</ref> The Vietnamese were recognised as an official minority under the PRK regime, and Overseas Vietnamese Associations were established in parts of Cambodia with sizeable Vietnamese populations.<ref>Heder (1995), p. 154</ref> The PRK government also identity cards were issued to them until the withdrawal of Vietnamese troops in 1990.<ref>Heder (1995), p. 135</ref>
 
Vietnamese migrant workers started to arrive from 1992 onwards due to the creation of new job opportunities by the [[United Nations Transitional Authority in Cambodia|UNTAC]] administration.<ref>Heder (1995), p. 62</ref> At the same time, the UNTAC administration allowed the opening of political offices and political parties such as [[FUNCINPEC]] and the [[Buddhist Liberal Democratic Party|BLDP]] began to propagate anti-Vietnamese sentiments among the populace to shore up electorate support in the [[1993 Cambodian general election|1993 general elections]].<ref>Heder (1995), p. 63</ref> In November 1992, the Khmer Rouge which controlled northwestern parts of Cambodia, passed a resolution to target systematic killings of Vietnamese soldiers and civilians.<ref>Heder (1995), p. 94</ref> The first guerrilla-style attacks by the Khmer Rouge on Vietnamese civilians started in December 1992, and Khmer Rouge soldiers justified the killings by claiming that some of the civilians were Vietnamese soldiers in disguise.<ref>Heder (1995), p. 95</ref> The spate of killings by Khmer Rouge prompted some 21,000 ethnic Vietnamese to flee to Vietnam in March 1993.<ref>Heder (1995), p. 262</ref>
 
In August 1994, the [[National Assembly of Cambodia]] introduced an immigration law which authorisesauthorised the deportation of illegal immigrants. The [[United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees|UNHCR]] perceivedassessed the law as singling out and targeting Vietnamese migrants in Cambodia, and; the Cambodian government laterhad steppedto inreassure tothe international assurecommunity that no mass deportations of Vietnamese refugees would be implemented. TheMeanwhile in the remote northwest, he Khmer Rouge continued to carry out sporadic attacks on Vietnamese civilians. untilThe theyKhmer Rouge formally surrendered to the government in 1999. Ethnicbut ethnic Vietnamese continue to face discrimination fromin Cambodian societyCambodia, andboth encounteredas physical intimidation from societythe general population and governmentadministrative threats by local authorities. Anti-Vietnamese are familiar rallying cries from politicians in especiallycampaigns during the general elections orand become even more acute when disputes betweenflared Cambodiain andthe news between the Vietnamtwo arisecountries.<ref>Amer (2013), p. 95</ref>
 
==Demographics==
Line 30 ⟶ 36:
===Population===
 
The Vietnamese are generally concentrated along the river banks of the Tonlé Sap lake and Mekong river which encompass the provinces of [[Siem Reap]], [[Kampong Chhnang Province|Kampong Chhnang]] and [[Pursat]].<ref>Ehrentraut (2013), p. 30</ref> Smaller populations may be found in Phnom Penh as well as southeastern provinces bordering Vietnam, namely [[Prey Veng Province|Prey Veng]], [[Svay Rieng Province|Svay Rieng]],<ref>Willmott (1967), p. 107</ref> [[Kampot Province|Kampot]], [[Kandal Province|Kandal]], [[Kratié Province|Kratié]]<ref name="Eh71"/> and [[Takéo Province|Takéo]].<ref name="Sch260"/> The Vietnamese population was at its largest in 1962 when the government census showed that they were the country's largest minority and reflected 3.8% of the country's population. Demographic researchers returned higher estimated numbers of Vietnamese than government censuses reflect. For example, in the 1960s, the number of resident Vietnamese may be as high as 400,000,<ref name="Tabeau48"/> while another Cambodian-based researcher, [[Michael Vickery]] had estimated the Vietnamese resident population to be between 200,000 and 300,000 in 1986. On the other hand, government censuses conducted during the 1980s put the figures to be no more than 60,000.<ref name="Sch261">Schliesinger (2015), p. 261</ref> The following population figures shows population figures of ethnic Vietnamese based on figures derived from government censuses:
 
{| class="wikitable" style="margin-top:0;"
Line 77 ⟶ 83:
 
===Education===
[[File:Tonlé Sap 07.jpg|thumb|An elementary school on the water in [[Tonle Sap]], donated by the [[People's Army of Vietnam]]]]
 
Field research carried out by [[Ethnology|ethnologists]] such as Stefan Ehrentraut shows that only a minority of Vietnamese children attend public schools, with figures varying across different provinces. In Kampong Chhnang and Siem Reap where the Vietnamese live along the river banks, enrolment into public schools fare below 10%, whereas in other provinces such as Kampot and Kratie the proportion are higher.<ref name="Eh80">Ehrentraut (2013), p. 80</ref> As the majority of Vietnamese do not carry citizenship papers, they were unable to enrol their children into public schools.<ref>Ang (2014), p. 11</ref> For those who send their children to schools, most of them only attend school for a few years and seldom complete [[Grade 12]] as Vietnamese parents were unable to afford school fees. Vietnamese students also faced difficulties in academic work, as classes are taught exclusively in the Khmer language, and Vietnamese children that grew up speaking Vietnamese at home have limited competency in Khmer.<ref>Ehrentraut (2013), p. 81</ref> In some Vietnamese communities based in the Tonle Sap and Mekong rivers, there are private schools that are run by Vietnamese community associations and Christian organisations. The private schools cater the teaching of the Vietnamese language, and are mostly attended by children of impoverished families.<ref>Ehrentraut (2013), p. 82</ref>
 
Line 94 ⟶ 100:
===Inter-ethnic relations===
 
Ethnic Khmers have a poor perception of the Vietnamese community, due to persistent feelings of communal animosity from the past history of Vietnamese rule over Cambodia.<ref>Ehrentraut (2013), pp. 86–87</ref> In 1958, a survey conducted by William Willmott upon high school students in Phnom Penh showed that relations with Chinese were generally rated as friendly, whereas Khmer students viewed their Vietnamese classmates with suspicion.<ref name="Wil35"/> Relations between the Vietnamese and Chinese are considerably better, as both ethnic groups share a close cultural affinity. Chinese males sometimes take Vietnamese wives, particularly in Phnom Penh and eastern parts of the country where there are large Chinese and Vietnamese communities.<ref>Willmott (1967), p. 42</ref> In recent years, field research carried out by Ehrentraut in 2013 suggested that ethnic relations between Vietnamese have deteriorated not only with the ethnic Khmer, but also with the [[Cham people|Cham]] and Chinese Cambodians.<ref>Ehrentraut (2013), p. 76</ref>
 
Most Vietnamese are unrepresented in the Cambodian [[Commune Council (Cambodia)|commune]] councils as they lack Cambodian citizenship.<ref>Ehrentraut (2013), p. 83</ref> According to respondents from Ehrentraut's field research, the majority of Cambodian commune chiefs and officials express support in excluding Vietnamese representatives from getting citizenship and participating in commune elections and meetings due to contempt.<ref name="Eh85"/> The Vietnamese appoint their own village heads, and convey community concerns Vietnamese community associations ([[Vietnamese language|Vietnamese]]: Tổng hội người Campuchia gốc Việt) that was first established in 2003. The community associations own limited assets and obtains funding from membership fees, donations from the Vietnamese embassy in Cambodia and sale of cemetery land from the Vietnamese communities.<ref name="Eh72">Ehrentraut (2013), p. 72</ref> The funds are subsequently used to address Vietnamese communal concerns which includes supporting religious places of worship and teaching of the Vietnamese language, as well as providing assistance to disadvantaged families. While the community associations have the tacit support of the Vietnamese community, the majority do not accept membership for fear of getting social stigma from mainstream Cambodian society. As of 2013, branches of these associations are established in 19 out of 23 provinces across Cambodia.<ref>Ehrentraut (2013), p. 73</ref>