Wikipedia talk:WikiProject China: Difference between revisions
Content deleted Content added
Anne Delong (talk | contribs) →Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Lan Yu: new section |
TI. Gracchus (talk | contribs) →Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Lan Yu: Source evaluation |
||
Line 232:
Dear China experts: Here's another old Afc submission that will soon be gone. It will need someone who can read the references to tell whether this is a notable topic. —[[User:Anne Delong|Anne Delong]] ([[User talk:Anne Delong|talk]]) 02:11, 25 March 2014 (UTC)
:About half of the reference links still work and appear to be acceptable secondary sources. It seems that most of the content of the article is well-supported. Lan Yu seems at least as notable to me as the other fashion designers in the China category of [[List_of_fashion_designers|this list]] whose entries haven't been challenged for notability. That said, I'm still a relatively unexperienced, and the criteria for notability are both subjective and debatable by reasonable people.
:If anyone is more familiar with fashion or biography notability guidelines, I'd value a second opinion, but to me it seems like this article just needs in-line citations and maybe an extra source or two to get it up to snuff. [[User:TI. Gracchus|TI. Gracchus]] ([[User talk:TI. Gracchus|talk]]) 18:53, 25 March 2014 (UTC)
| |||